Insurance commissioner visits Dare,
schedules hearing on rate increase for rentals
A proposal that could see homeowners’ insurance
rental properties skyrocket more than 20 percent has furrowed many
brows on the Outer Banks, and even North Carolina Insurance
Commissioner Wayne Goodwin may find it problematic.
Responding to insurance experts who questioned the justification for
the increase, Goodwin announced on Monday that a public hearing on the
rate increase proposal for non-owner occupied residences has been
scheduled for June 21.
That would be the first time in 18 years the state Department of
Insurance has held a hearing on a rate filing, said Willo Kelly,
government affairs director for the Outer Banks Home Builders
Association and the Outer Banks Association of Realtors.
“This is a pretty big deal,” she said.
The commissioner, a Democrat elected in 2008, had visited the Outer
Banks last week for two days, meeting with realtors, homebuilders,
insurance agents, and political groups.
“There’s a lot of misinformation out there,” Goodwin told members of
the Democratic Women of Dare on Thursday. “There’s a lot of folks who
think the insurance commissioner asks for rates to be raised.
“Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong!”
Rates are set by the North Carolina Rate Bureau, an independent
organization representing all property insurance companies in the
state. Only the legislature, he said, could change the way rates are
Although Goodwin was unable to directly address the proposal because of
a pending lawsuit, he “did let us know that he does understand,” said
Robin Mann, Democratic Women first vice-president.
“It did feel good to know that the consumer has someone who is
listening to us,” she said, “and is as concerned as us with what’s
happening in the insurance industry.”
Mann, as chairwoman of the Outer Banks Chamber of Commerce, had sent a
letter to the department on Jan. 26 objecting to the proposed rate
“At a time when home values are low and foreclosures are abundant, the
effects of an increase in dwelling policy rates could prove
devastating,” she wrote.
Dare County had earlier sued the Insurance Department over
previous rate increases in homeowners insurance. The matter is before
the state Supreme Court, which has not yet agreed to hear the case.
After the recent rate increase was filed on Jan. 4 by the bureau,
Goodwin ordered a public comment period “as a way to increase
transparency and engage the general public in the ratemaking process,”
according to a Feb. 21 department news release. The comment
period had closed on Jan. 31.
Kelly said that while the average increase statewide for dwelling
policies would be 20.9 percent, according to Rate Bureau figures, the
rate for extended coverage --- which covers wind and hail damage --- is
41.65 percent statewide.
But that same extended coverage on the coast would cost up to ten times
what it would cost elsewhere in the state, she said. In Charlotte, for
instance, the policy would cost $22 per $15,000 of coverage; on the
Outer Banks the same policy would cost $222 per $15,000 of coverage.
Annual premiums for rental or investment dwellings on the coast would
increase about $1,000 a year on a $300,000 structure, Kelly said. The
region already has a higher deductible than the rest of the state, she
added, and the proposal does not reflect the stronger state building
“Now with the economy the way it is, everybody’s at the breaking
point,” Kelly said. A statewide catastrophic fund should be created to
address homeowner losses in a fairer way, she said.
From 2003 through 2007, she said, the insurance industry in the state
made about $1 billion, calculating the difference between premiums and
losses. But even with Hurricane Isabel, the average loss for wind on
the coast over the same period was less than $5,000.
“So it’s not that we have these huge expensive losses,” Kelly
said. “We just keep seeing we’re paying more and more and we’re getting
less and less.”
To read the very long and complicated rate filing, click