Supporters of bill to overturn ORV rule find a friend on Senate committee
By IRENE NOLAN
Supporters of a Senate bill to set aside the National Park Service’s
final plan and special regulation on off-road vehicles at the Cape
Hatteras National Seashore found a Democratic friend today at a Senate
Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., took up the cause, admonishing a Park
Service witness and saying that the agency had become an “adversary”
and “enemy” of the people who are suffering hardships because of the
One more Democrat on their side, and the legislation might have a chance to be favorably voted out of the committee.
The Senate’s Energy and Natural Resources Committee had a hearing this
afternoon on S 2372, a bipartisan bill introduced on April 26 by U.S.
Sen. Richard Burr, R-N.C., and co-sponsored by U.S. Sen. Kay Hagan,
The title of the bill is the Preserving Public Access to Cape Hatteras
Beaches Act. It would abolish the final ORV plan and rule and return
the management of the seashore to the 2007 Interim Protected Species
Management Plan until the Secretary of the Department of Interior and
Director of the National Park Service devise a new ORV plan and final
rule that meets the requirements set forth in the legislation.
A companion bill, with the same language, was passed by the U.S. House
of Representatives last week as part of a package of 14 bills on parks
and public lands.
That’s the most success any of the bills to return the seashore to the
interim strategy has had in the House, and it passed on the third try.
Jones has introduced a similar bill twice before.
A similar bill has also been introduced in the U.S.
Senate, but the Energy and Natural Resources Committee voted it down in
2008 in a split along party lines – Democrats voting against sending
the bill out of committee, which essentially killed it, and Republicans
So the Democratic senator from West Virginia’s impassioned support of
the bill was a welcome surprise to the folks from Dare County who went
to Washington to hear the testimony.
Other National Park Service related bills were part of today’s hearing and
they ran the gamut from the Cape Hatteras access to legislation that would change the official name of Alaska’s Mt. McKinley to
Fewer witnesses were involved than in the house subcommittee hearing on the legislation.
The first panel included Herbert Frost, associate director of Natural
Resource Stewardship and Science for the National Park Service and
Ingrid Kolb, director of the Office of Management in the U.S.
Department of Energy.
The second panel included the mayor of Oak Ridge, Tenn., who supported
a bill to establish the Manhattan Project National Historical Park, and
Warren Judge, chairman of the Dare County Board of Commissioners, and
Derb Carter, director of the North Carolina office of the Southern
Environmental Law Center, who both addressed S 2372.
Frost’s remarks were identical to those he made in the House subcommittee hearing, noting that the Park Service “strongly opposes” the bill.
Judge strongly defended the bill,
addressing the issues he has in the past – denial of access, the
rigidity of the plan that allows the superintendent no opportunity to
manage according to conditions on the ground, the fact seashore was
created as a “recreational” area, the size of the closures, and the
economic damage to Hatteras Island.
Carter defended the final rule,
noting its predecessor, the 2008 consent decree that settled a lawsuit,
has meant that nesting success of birds and turtles has rebounded, and
that tourism is booming in Dare County.
None of that testimony was surprising, but then came Joe Manchin.
He said many of his constituents have been coming to the seashore for generations and indicated that he had visited many times.
He first spoke directly to the Park Service’s witness.
“The majority of the people who live there are totally in favor of
2372,” he said, “and those who have filed lawsuits do not live there.”
The Park Service, he said, talks about increasing access for sportsmen,
but he noted “that isn’t what this bill is all about.”
“Don’t you consider the people who live there and their livelihoods?” he asked.
“It’s unbelievable the hardship you are placing on those people,”
Manchin continued, noting the Park Service had become an “adversary”
and an “enemy.”
At the conclusion of the hearing, he asked Judge and Carter if they wanted to add anything.
Carter remarked that last week, 50 of the 65 miles of seashore beaches were “open.”
That allowed Judge to have the last word, again disputing much of what Carter had said.
Bobby Outten, Dare County manager and attorney, said afterward that
Manchin “just got it,” referring to the restrictive nature of the final
rule and the problems it has brought to the Hatteras and Ocracoke
“I’m happy because we finally have people who are listening to us,”
Judge said. “We’re happy that after all these years, someone is talking
He said the Dare County delegation had good meetings with members of the Burr and Hagan staffs.
The next step for the bill is for the Senate committee to move to mark-up and vote on it.
Assuming all of the committee Republicans support it, as they did in
the House, it would need only two Democratic votes to be reported out
favorably and perhaps go to the floor of the Senate.
An archived video of the hearing is available on the committee’s website at http://www.energy.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2012/6/national-parks-subcommittee-hearing
FOR MORE INFORMATION
The Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources website:
The members of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee:
To find and contact your senators: